Intimidation practices of the tobacco industry: current situation and recommendations from researchers
November 20, 2026
Par: National Committee Against Smoking
Dernière mise à jour: November 20, 2026
Temps de lecture: 9 minutes
Tobacco control efforts have contributed to significant public health progress. However, researchers, public officials, and the associations involved can face pressure to challenge their work, limit their activities, or influence regulatory decisions.
An article published in the journal Tobacco Control by an international team of researchers and tobacco control practitioners examined the forms of intimidation encountered in this area, their consequences, and ways to respond to them.[1]. This report draws on published research as well as the experience of the authors and their colleagues. It does not, therefore, present a new survey measuring the frequency of these practices across the entire sector. Its objective is to provide guidance for those affected and for the organizations responsible for supporting them. The authors consider that documented intimidation is part of the tobacco industry's influence strategies. They nevertheless point out that attributing an incident to a particular company can be difficult, especially when intermediaries are involved or when the events involve clandestine or criminal activities. In some cases, the industry's involvement cannot be definitively established.
Various forms of intimidation, sometimes difficult to attribute
The article defines intimidation as a set of actions perceived as threatening, coercive, harassing, or excessively burdensome, likely to discourage or restrict the work of an individual or public health organization. It emphasizes that legitimate actions can become instruments of pressure when used to impose a disproportionate burden, discredit, or deter.
The practices identified include public denigration, particularly on social media, and questioning of the competence or integrity of individuals; complaints addressed to employers, institutions, authorities or scientific journals; requests for access to information used to mobilize time and resources or disrupt an activity; threats of prosecution and legal proceedings; attempts at bribery or co-optation; theft, surveillance and threats of physical violence; and, more rarely, actual reported physical violence.
In the literature review cited by the authors, which focuses on tobacco, alcohol, and ultra-processed foods, public denigration is the most frequently reported form of intimidation. However, these results describe the facts recorded in the publications examined, and not the actual prevalence of each practice among all tobacco control professionals. The examples presented concern several countries and situations of varying severity. Media smear campaigns, pressure on association leadership, surveillance, legal threats, or threats targeting relatives. The article encourages a distinction between substantive criticism, which is part of scientific and public debate, and behaviors intended to intimidate or obstruct work.
Individual, organizational and political consequences
The effects of bullying can be psychological, professional, material, or physical. Targeted individuals may experience fear, anxiety, distress, or a feeling of isolation. The most serious incidents can result in injury and, in rare reported cases, death.
For organizations, managing attacks consumes time, funding, and skills that are no longer available for their originally planned activities. It can also strain relationships with partners and public policymakers. Some teams then reduce their media exposure, suspend projects deemed risky, or redirect their work. Individuals may also leave the sector or decide against entering it. These effects can contribute to a form of self-censorship and slow down research, advocacy, and policy development. Researchers cite, in particular, work conducted in Virginia, USA, where industry interventions coincided with a shift in actions toward objectives considered less threatening to its interests. This example illustrates one possible mechanism, but it does not, on its own, allow us to quantify the overall effect of intimidation on tobacco control policies.
Exposure to risks and response opportunities are unequal. They depend in particular on the political and legal context, available resources, institutional support, job security, and career stage.
A practical framework for preparing, responding, and learning from experience
The article proposes a three-step framework, «Prepare–Respond–Reflect,» designed to organize the prevention and management of bullying. These proposals are neither exhaustive nor prescriptive. They must be adapted to local circumstances and do not replace the responsibilities of institutions and governments.
Initially, preparation involves identifying risks and planning the necessary resources before an incident occurs. The authors recommend being familiar with documented tactics, defining rules of integrity and relationships with industry stakeholders, and then establishing a risk management plan. This plan should specify the key contacts, methods for preserving evidence, and response options. It also involves anticipating legal and communication needs, strengthening cybersecurity, identifying support networks, and training teams, particularly those at the beginning of their careers. The authors also suggest not automatically interpreting an attack as a personal failure: some pressures may be a reaction to work with real-world implications. Furthermore, they recommend distinguishing between substantive criticisms and industry-related pressures, and assessing risks before responding.
Secondly, when an incident occurs, the article recommends first taking a step back, assessing the situation, and protecting those involved. The response must consider the risk of escalation, further exposure, or legal consequences. Depending on the circumstances, it may range from no direct response to a public clarification or institutional intervention. Suggested measures include retaining dated emails, letters, and screenshots, activating the risk management plan, and seeking appropriate support. The authors recommend keeping in mind the actual target audience for the communication, rather than engaging in prolonged exchanges that could distract from the initial work. When appropriate and sufficiently safe, the organization or partners can speak on behalf of the targeted individual. Reporting to specialized networks or publicizing the incident can also be considered, after evaluating their benefits and risks.
Thirdly, after an incident, the analysis should identify what worked, the shortcomings of the system, and the necessary improvements. Sharing experiences can strengthen team preparedness, reduce isolation, and preserve institutional memory. This approach aims both to improve procedures and to acknowledge the human impact of bullying.
A protection that also relies on institutions
The article emphasizes that protection cannot rely primarily on the individual's ability to resist pressure. It proposes treating bullying as an occupational hazard requiring a coordinated response.
Governments are urged to fully implement the WHO Framework Convention on Tobacco Control (FCTC), particularly Article 5.3 concerning the protection of public policies against the commercial interests of the tobacco industry. The authors also advocate for legal and political support for targeted individuals, greater transparency in interactions, and measures to limit opportunities for interference.
Furthermore, employers and institutions should implement prevention, reporting, and response procedures, train staff, and offer legal assistance, communication support, and psychological support as needed. The article emphasizes that those targeted should not be penalized for the attacks they endure.
Funders, for their part, are encouraged to integrate these risks into their programs and to provide flexible resources for digital security, legal advice and team well-being.
Scientific journals and professional associations are encouraged to support the documentation and analysis of intimidation and to rigorously manage conflicts of interest. The authors specifically propose that Journals refuse to publish research related to the tobacco industry. They also recommend that professional associations adopt rules excluding representatives of this industry and related actors from their membership, events, and governing bodies.
Finally, the authors call for the development of support networks, mentoring, and research on the effectiveness of responses. Their central proposal is to combine practical measures tailored to individual situations with sustainable institutional protections, while taking into account differences in context and the limitations of available knowledge.
AD
[1]Banks E., Evans-Reeves K., Assunta M., et al, Working in tobacco control: research-informed and experience-informed approaches to surviving and thriving amid bullying industry, Tobacco Control, published on November 18, 2026, accessed on November 19, 2026